NaamKyun.com Discussion Forum

Now that is what I'd call a lineage chart!

Hmm, let's see now...

thank you alot

If you made it yourself you can add that Master Richard Chan is in Canada

Thank you

This chart is very out of date of course, my master is not listed under there at all. Good to see someone trying to put something together at least.

I didn't see Chan Tai-Hing under Tang-Fong's line either.

Incredible the amount of work and research that must have gone into it. Even if it's not 100% accurate or up to date, props for such detailed work.

Eric, do you know who created it and do they want updated information submitted?

Yui

Haha, because you know what happens next, is this guy gets ambitious about it, next thing you know, he publishes it all in a book...

[quote="Frank Bolte"]checking the list I see some people who dont even know more then 2 pillar sets,they actually teach different styles and just learned a few sets but never trained serious hung kuen,....quote]

You are right about that, Frank.
It's partly taken over from some other lists that circulate around the www.

Copied over, and over again, without any serious research.

It is indeed an ambitious undertaking. No small feat for sure. A lot of time must've gone into it.

Still, as South Paw had mentioned, it is based on what's all over the web, regurgitated. Many of the ones listed are the Western students yet, for every one of them, there are perhaps many more of the daily students who actually live in HK/China and train more regularly with the Sifus there. They're the local unknowns to the internet community.

Not many are mentioned but, then again, such a list could never be completely accurate or up to date as students always come and go. There are closer, long-time students who are not mentioned at all, but it was a valiant effort nonetheless.

I myself could never have come up with even one tenth of that, so whomever took part in it gets an A-grade for trying lol

Well Tid Sin, you give this A-grade to Maurizio Zanetti, he made it. To me it is just an E-grade, a total failure. This because it is showing legendary ancestors, illusional lineages and too many students.

Yeah, I give an A for effort alone. The end result of his efforts, however, fall short of the mark, agreed. Without accuracy, history becomes cloudy, vague; false. Not worth perpetuating. Next...

That is the best lineage chart I have ever seen so detailed and accurate, wow!